Understanding Your Right to Appraisal in Insurance Claims

If you’ve ever been in a car accident and felt like your insurance company didn’t offer enough to cover your pre-loss repairs, you’re not alone. One clause in your insurance policy that many people overlook is the Right to Appraisal clause. It’s often hidden deep within the fine print, yet it can be invaluable if you and your insurer cannot agree on the cost of repairing your vehicle back to its pre-loss condition.

So what is it, exactly?

The Right to Appraisal gives you the ability to challenge your insurance company if you believe they are undervaluing your repair estimate.

What is the Right to Appraisal?

The Right to Appraisal is a section of your insurance policy that allows you to contest the amount your insurer is willing to pay for repairs. This may also apply to the vehicle's value if it is deemed a total loss. It’s important to note that this clause is not for disputing fault in the accident; it solely addresses disagreements regarding repair costs or vehicle valuation.

How Does the Right to Appraisal Work?

Here’s how the Right to Appraisal typically operates:

1. Choose Your Appraisers: Both you and the insurance company will each select an independent appraiser.

2. Select an Umpire: The two chosen appraisers will then agree on a neutral third party, known as an umpire.

3. Review Evidence: Together, these three professionals will review the evidence regarding the repair costs.

4. Final Decision: If two out of the three appraisers reach an agreement, that decision is final and legally binding.

   
   

When Should You Use It?

You should consider using the Right to Appraisal if:

• Your repair shop's estimate exceeds what the insurance company has approved.

• There is a disagreement specifically regarding the cost to restore your car to its pre-loss condition.

• You have already tried negotiating with your adjuster but have reached an impasse.

  
  

However, the Right to Appraisal is not suitable for disputes regarding fault or coverage. This process exclusively applies to questions of value.

If you find yourself in this situation, you don’t have to tackle it alone. Speak with your repair shop; they can assist you in understanding the next steps and determine whether the Right to Appraisal is the best course of action.

Why the Right to Appraisal Matters

Many people mistakenly believe that the insurance adjuster’s assessment is final. This isn’t necessarily the case. The Right to Appraisal clause empowers you, particularly if you are collaborating with a reputable repair shop that understands the true costs of proper repairs.

Talk to Your Shop First

If your insurance estimate feels inadequate to cover the necessary repairs, don't panic. Start by engaging with your repair shop. Here’s why that makes sense:

✅ Shops Understand the Process

Trusted repair shops, like ours, see situations like this frequently. We understand what repairs should genuinely cost and can identify when an insurance estimate overlooks essential components. Our team can help you compare estimates and clarify any discrepancies.

✅ Guidance Through the Process

Many customers are unaware of their Right to Appraisal clause. We've assisted clients who faced low insurance offers by walking them through how the appraisal process works and what to expect at each stage.

✅ You Don't Have to Go It Alone

In certain instances, we can coordinate with appraisers or provide documentation to strengthen your case. This support can make the entire process more straightforward and less stressful.

Real Talk: Understanding Your Rights

Insurance companies don’t always get their evaluations right. However, with the Right to Appraisal, you have a mechanism to challenge their estimates without the need for a court battle. Ultimately, we want your car to be repaired correctly—back to its pre-loss condition—rather than just accepting the cheapest option the insurance provider will approve.

So, before you accept a low estimate, come talk to us. We'll guide you through your options and help you determine if beginning the appraisal process aligns with your needs. Your safety, your vehicle, and your peace of mind are our priorities, and we’re here to support you throughout this journey.

If you're still unsure, remember that consulting with experts can clarify any aspects of your policy, making your experience easier and ensuring you get the coverage you deserve.

---

Learn more about your insurance rights here.