top of page

Is Your Car a Total Loss? Here's What You Should Know.

Sean Garland
Nov 10
3 min read

Finding out your vehicle has been declared a total loss can be stressful, especially when you weren't expecting it. But what does that actually mean, and what options do you have?


At Professional Auto Body & Paint, we want drivers to understand the process so they can make informed decisions after an accident.

Damaged vehicle on a tow truck following a collision in Portland, Oregon, illustrating the auto insurance total loss process.

What Does "Total Loss" Mean?


A vehicle is considered a total loss when an insurance company determines that repairing it is no longer financially practical compared to its value. That doesn't necessarily mean your vehicle is beyond repair. Sometimes, even damage that looks relatively minor can result in a total loss due to expensive parts, labor, hidden damage, or safety-related repairs.


Who makes that decision?


The insurance company, not the auto body shop. Our responsibility is to thoroughly assess the damage and prepare a repair estimate based on what is needed to restore your vehicle properly. The insurance company then reviews the repair costs and your vehicle's value to determine whether it will be repaired or declared a total loss.


What Happens Next?


If your vehicle is declared a total loss, your insurance company will typically offer a settlement based on its Actual Cash Value (ACV), which is what your vehicle was worth immediately before the accident.


This valuation considers factors such as:

  • Year, make, model, and mileage

  • Vehicle condition before the accident

  • Trim level and optional features

  • Prices of comparable vehicles in your area


If you accept the settlement and surrender the vehicle, the insurance company generally takes possession of it. If you still have an auto loan, your lender may receive some or all of the settlement.

However, there's something important to understand before accepting an offer.


Can You Dispute a Total Loss Settlement?


Yes! You don't have to accept the insurance company's first offer if you believe your vehicle is worth more.


Insurance companies use valuation reports to determine your vehicle's value, but these reports aren't always accurate. They may overlook optional features, underestimate your vehicle's condition, or use comparable vehicles that don't accurately reflect its market value.

While you can research similar vehicles and provide your own evidence, insurance companies may not give customer-submitted valuations much consideration.


This is why we strongly recommend working with an independent automobile appraiser if you disagree with your settlement.


An independent appraiser can professionally evaluate your vehicle's pre-accident value, identify errors in the insurance company's report, and provide documented evidence to support your dispute.

If you're filing through your own insurance, your policy may also include a Right to Appraisal provision, which provides a formal process for resolving disagreements over the value of your loss.

Hiring an appraiser doesn't guarantee a higher settlement, but it can significantly strengthen your position when negotiating with the insurance company.

In Oregon, you may also be able to receive the undisputed portion of your settlement while continuing to pursue additional compensation, subject to certain requirements.


Should You Buy Back Your Totaled Vehicle?


In some cases, the insurance company may allow you to keep your totaled vehicle rather than surrender it.

While this might seem appealing, we generally recommend against buying back a totaled vehicle, particularly if you intend to repair and continue driving it.

Repair costs can add up quickly, especially if hidden damage is discovered. A salvage or rebuilt title can also affect the vehicle's resale value and make it more difficult to insure or sell in the future.

Additionally, the insurance company typically deducts the vehicle's salvage value from your settlement, leaving you with less money to cover potentially expensive repairs.

For most everyday drivers, accepting a fair settlement and replacing the vehicle is often the safer and more practical option.


What About Your Rental Car?


If you've been using a rental vehicle, keep in mind that rental coverage may change once your vehicle is declared a total loss.

Rental benefits depend on your insurance coverage and whether you're filing through your own insurer or the at-fault driver's insurance.

We recommend confirming your rental return deadline with the insurance company as soon as possible to avoid unexpected out-of-pocket expenses.


We're Here to Help


At Professional Auto Body & Paint, our priority is ensuring vehicles are assessed and repaired properly according to manufacturer guidelines.

Although we don't determine whether a vehicle is a total loss or decide its settlement value, we're happy to help explain the process and point you toward resources, including independent appraisers, if you believe your settlement deserves a closer look.

Remember, just because an insurance company makes an offer doesn't mean you have to accept an inaccurate valuation.

Have questions about your collision repair or total loss claim? Contact Professional Auto Body & Paint at 503-281-1103 or visit www.propdx.net.

This article is for general informational purposes and is not legal advice. Insurance policies and individual claim circumstances may vary.

Comments


bottom of page